I read an article on MSN Travel today – I’m actually quite surprised at the tone of the article, and the negative comments towards travel agents. I’d like to think that I give a positive view of all types of holidays on Travel Rants, and don’t sway one particular way [tell me if you don’t think this is true!]

Avoid the travel agent altogether and get online to research, compare and book at a time to suit you. There are also several excellent hotel and holiday review sites which can provide ideas and recommendations and reveal facts and tips about destination that you won’t find in a brochure. You can then contact hotels direct and negotiate on price.
Yes, it’s true that the internet is a great tool for reading hotel reviews, it allows us to be inspired through travel videos and guides, and yes, I have organised DIY holidays, booked package holidays, and both have worked out cheaper than the other due to the time of the year I am travelling, where I am travelling to and many other factors.
I felt that the travel article was very one-sided, and didn’t go into what issues a consumer could come up against if they DIY’ed rather than booking a bonded dynamic or package holiday. It’s important that the consumer doesn’t just think of the cost, it’s important that the dangers of booking a DIY holiday are highlighted and the importance of adequate travel insurance.
If you have an unanswered travel question please feel free to contact me. Alternatively, receive the popular and free travel rants newsletter delivered to your inbox every week by signing-up or subscribe for updates via RSS.

Nathan | 20 June, 2007 at 12:30 pm
Well said Darren. That ‘zero-sum’ attitude, where because one option is helpful the other must be unhelpful, is such a bad way to approach booking travel.
It depends what you’re booking, when you’re booking it and who you talk to. As you’ve said countless times in the past, cover all your bases if you want to find the right product at the right price.
pam | 20 June, 2007 at 2:37 pm
Consider the source: MSN. I’d be inclined to suspect that MSN, which is run by Microsoft, which spun off Expedia, would have a vested interest in promoting online travel resources. MSN wants your eyeballs on their screens. I don’t know that I’d go so far as to say that they’re blatantly tipping the scales, but I do think that their editorial strategy would have an unsurprising preference for their own product.
Darren Cronian | 20 June, 2007 at 2:59 pm
Good points raised Pam.
To be honest, it’s the first time I have read MSN Travel and the headline and content surprised me. I’ve tried to find the writers contact details to ask some questions, but I’ve not being successful – yet.
There were some good points raised in the article, but I felt wound up that readers weren’t made aware of the disadvantages of booking a DIY holiday, just like there was no mention of the advantage of package holidays.
Good to see you back on the blog Pam.
Lisa Corcoran | 21 June, 2007 at 8:02 am
It does look very one-sided.and Pam states a good case above.
Although I find the internet very useful when booking a holiday some people still like to talk to a ‘person’ and there is no right or wrong way, it’s just personal preference.
It also depends on time and for many people it is easier to hand their holiday plans over to a travel agent and everything is sorted for them rather than spending hours on the internet!
Dee Edwards | 21 June, 2007 at 5:21 pm
I think it’s a bizarre broadbrush statement, particularly given the section above this section is entitled ‘ Explore all your travel options’!!
Additionally, anyone who thinks they know enough to write an article about saving money in buying travel should surely know a bit about the industry and the pressures high street travel agents have been under. Their margin is hardly going to break the bank for the average consumer or be of poor value given the advice, the bonding etc already referred to.
Another point is surely with some package holidays, they can’t be DIYd for less? One place I’m thinking of is Luxor in Egypt. If I wanted to fly there and stay all inclusive in a 4 star hotel, I don’t think I could do it for anywhere near what the mainstream packages cost? (Not that I’d want to do it it).
One last point is that if you have a relationship with a travel agent, you’ll find out about holidays that interest you that might not necessarily be available on the likes of Expedia, or rather you may not find them in a pull versus push scenario. Some very special holidays are certainly not available on the likes of Expedia, my company’s holidays are not but are available through travel agents who have taken the time to find out enough about them.
Darren Cronian | 21 June, 2007 at 11:11 pm
Spot on Dee.
Last year I visited Prague, I did this DIY, because it was actually cheap, but later in the year I booked a package holiday to Kos, becuase it was much cheaper than flight and accommodation.
We are all different, and let’s be honest, if you were looking for a holiday during the peak season, I think you would struggle to find a flight and accommodation cheaper than a package holiday.
Jacky | 21 June, 2007 at 11:16 pm
Am I the only person in this planet who thinks that expedia is over priced, and over rated.
I don’t know what all the big fuss is about.
Darren Cronian | 21 June, 2007 at 11:34 pm
Jacky, I have to agree about the prices.
I’ve never found any decent deals on Expedia, all seem to be pretty expensive.
Same goes with Lastminute.com
Rohan | 21 June, 2007 at 11:46 pm
I read the article, and I do agree with her on some points; the price increase of holidays during the school holidays is not on, and, yes I know holiday companies have to make a living, but really at the expense of parents?
Other than that I agree with you guys, she’s not researched this topic, jumped in with both feet, and not warned holidaymakers of the dangers - in fact Darren, why didn’t you pick up that she’s not mentioned travel insurance at any point in that article?
Kyle | 21 June, 2007 at 11:50 pm
Yaoooooooooohooo hit the big boys!! MSN are well known for writing nonsense that promotes their own products, and someone has finally woken up and seen them for what they are.
Darren Cronian | 22 June, 2007 at 1:17 am
Rohan, I agree with you on the price of holidays during the school holidays, but that won’t change anytime, because it’ll just mean that holidays out of school holidays during low seasons will increase, and that’ll upset even more holidaymakers.
I’ve got an interview with an newspaper reporter tomorrow to discuss just the issue.
Regarding travel insurance, I didn’t pick up on that but good point. As travel companies, writers, media, everyone should be educating consumers of the dangers of travelling without insurance.
Trev | 22 June, 2007 at 3:36 am
What a joke MSN are. Talk about brainwashing their readers. I am glad you raised this, as they have been doing this on just about any product or service that MSN offer.
Michelle | 22 June, 2007 at 7:44 pm
I use the internet to book my holidays religiously every year and always go direct but will always go and check the hotels/apartments etc on a travel agents website.
They do charge an absolute fortune during school holidays which is why we go direct (plus its always cheaper) so not sure whether i agree to ditch them or not, they only thing I think they are good for is the star rating of the accomodation!
Kay | 23 June, 2007 at 10:53 pm
Cheapskate consumers and ignorant media annoy the life out of me.
I am a Travel Consultant with a global travel retailer and have been in the industry for 6 years now. People want the cheapest and don’t seem to realise that things are generally cheap for a reason. They book things themselves and when things go wrong and their dream holiday goes up in smoke, they have the cheek to come to us to fix it! We are professionals in our industry and like professionals in any other industry, such as estate agent, lawyer….if you employ the services of someone who knows what they are doing, you don’t expect them to offer their services for free.
Darren Cronian | 23 June, 2007 at 11:18 pm
Kay,
Thanks for your comments and good points.
I do agree that I think we all want something cheap, but then complain when something isn’t up to what we think the standard should be. I don’t think you will ever change that - it’s human nature.
Michelle,
I agree that the price during the school holidays is shocking, but they are occassions where booking a package holiday is much cheaper than booking direct, and the flights can be just as expensive as package holidays sometimes.
Kevin May | 24 June, 2007 at 12:08 am
agree with many of the comments. one small point: when did everyone start automatically assuming online is cheaper??
Darren: you mentioned Expedia and Lastminute.com, both big online travel agencies. Lastminute.com’s proposition has always been last-minute, not cheapest…
Darren Cronian | 24 June, 2007 at 12:21 am
It could be cheaper.
It depends on destination, season plus many other factors.
With the increase in flight prices though cheap DIY breaks could be a thing of the past.
Lee Harrison (owner Select World Travel) | 26 June, 2007 at 9:38 am
http://dontbookyourholidayonline.com/
Am I loving this new site from classic collection ![]()
Darren Cronian | 29 June, 2007 at 7:41 am
Lee, I am having trouble understanding this.
If companies like yours are against people booking their holiday online, why do you spend alot of time promoting your blog and website?
I know you don’t offer complete booking online, but still ![]()
Kevin May | 29 June, 2007 at 7:48 am
Darren: Lee is actually doing exactly the right thing. Ensuring his business is multi-channel in how it distributes its products.
Whether that is talking to customers face-to-face in his branch, on the phone, or providing them information online…it is having as many touchpoints with the consumers that is important.
This is why we gave Select World Travel one of Sm@rt Agent Awards last year.
Here is the article: http://travolution.co.uk/Articles/2006/09/22/481/Sm%40rt+Agent+winner+September+2006+-+Select+World+Travel.html
klm, ed, travo
20 responses to “Dump the Travel Agent say MSN Travel”