By Darren Cronian on Monday, April 23rd, 2007

Well, did anyone watch tonight with Trevor McDonald, on ITV? Interesting to hear that the government are looking at holiday bonding, and are proposing a levy on all tickets – let me guess who will be paying this levy?

A One-sided View of DIY Holidays

The programme featured the dangers of booking dynamic or DIY holidays, and whilst I do think it’s very important that consumers are made aware of disadvantages of these types of holiday, I thought that the programme was very one-sided.

According to the programme, over 11million people this year will book a DIY holiday, and why is this? Because consumers want affordable holidays, and flexibility – yes they will be stories of nightmare DIY holidays, but I wonder how this compares with nightmare package holidays?


Related posts




Subscribe to our feed Stumble this page Bookmark page

14 responses to “A One-sided View of DIY Holidays”

Interestingly Darren, our first Podcast ,http://www.selectworld.travel/destination-essentials/2007/4/21/select-world-travel-podcast-caa-announces-new-atol-protection-contribution-scheme.html
( Don’t laugh too much) covers the fact that AITO are welcoming the CAA’s plans to levy a £1 ( Yes just £1) charge to offer protection.
I didn’t find the programme 1 sided, in fact I don’t think it went far enough.
Consumers are not aware of the Pitfalls and don’t read the small print, If Surveyed how many people booking seperate Flights and Seperate Accommodation would Know what the term ” Principle” actually means and exactly what they are actually covered for?.
A lot of Accommodation suppliers are refusing to adopt principle status.
For every satisfied Do-It-Yourselfer, unfortunatly there are an equal amount of People left very dissatisfied and out of pocket
I Expect this year will also reveal a lot of Hotels over-booking, Flight changes or cancellations, On arrival, no mention of the reservation, Building works, People taken ill suddenly, Companys disappearing, I could go on and on.
Unfortunatly Clients want to pay less and less, they want something for nothing and the Message is Clear, BOOK AT YOUR OWN PERIL. If it Goes Wrong you are on your own.
Pay the £1 levy and have the backing of a reputable Tour Operator and Travel Agencies, and have complete peace of mind.

Darren Cronian | 24 April, 2007 at 9:15 am

Hi Lee,

I need another cheap break in October – I’ll be in touch.

I know you’re a genuine person, and you say it as it is, so I trust what you say, but I do wonder if some travel companies are more worried about DIY holidays because of the competition, i.e. 11million holidaymakers booking DIY, and not because they are worried about consumer’s safety?

Re. Accommodation only providers. Take an example of a business which promotes holiday homes, the owner of the villa advertises on the site, how could they get involved in bonding through an association like Travel Trust Association?

I’ve mentioned this [not on this blog] on many occasions, that I think there should be an association and a type of bonding for accommodation only providers. Does the TTA, accept applications from accommodation only companies?

I think accommodation only companies would be willing to join an association if it means that holidaymakers are going to be safer abroad. Bonding is not an area I know a great deal about, having not worked in the travel industry.

Karen Bryan | 24 April, 2007 at 11:10 am

I didn’t watch the programme last night partly because I was working on my website and partly because it sounded as though it was just going to be all the horror stories about DIY holidays,

I have been on countless DIY holidays over the years and never had any problems. However I am aware of potential problems and am willing to take that risk for the low price and flexibility. However if there was a low cost “safety net” bonding I would probably pay for this, just for the extra security and peace of mind.

I do agree with you, Lee, that some people are looking for something for nothing and to much pressure to reduce prices can lead to declining standards of quality and protection. Interested to hear that you have started podcasts. I received a Podcast Factory yesterday, a prize from a competition on a French news website. The box has the usual, “up and running in minutes” on the box but not being very technically minded, I’ve had no joy. just had to send an SOS to my son to come and assist.

Lee Harrison (owner Select World Travel) | 24 April, 2007 at 11:40 am

For information on TTA you can contact
Malcolm Byrne
Travel Trust Association
Albion House
3rd Floor
High Street
Woking
Surrey
Gu21 6BD
Tel 0870 8890577
or http://www.traveltrust.co.uk

I Do think Darren, that an important point came out of last nights programme, that a Client who had booked 2 adults and 2 Children would have been better off paying as 4 Adults when he booked with one of the Major Operators. The Top 4 Tour operators should not be allowed to get away with having more than 1 way of pricing a holiday!! Not only is this confusing to the Client, it’s confusing to us as well when entering the details. At Least with an Independent Operator, Pricing is fair and you know exactly what you are paying for.
The Industry must do a lot more with regards to fair pricing, and I hope that the necessary Authorities clamp down hard on Operators who flout the Pricing Wars

James | 24 April, 2007 at 11:42 am

Hi, was just wondering how you can justify the statement “For every satisfied Do-It-Yourselfer, unfortunatly there are an equal amount of People left very dissatisfied and out of pocket”

Are you saying that 50% of all D.I.Y. holidaymakers are not happy and /or overcharged?? It would be interesting to see the statistical evidence of this….

Rohan | 24 April, 2007 at 9:12 pm

Sorry, but 50% is rubbish.

This programme highlighted an example where someone was stranded in Italy and they had to find their way home via train. If this is the only nightmare story that they could find then it’s pretty poor.

That story was featured over a year ago.

Just compare the prices DIY £600 Package £900. Is the extra security worth £300?

Darren Cronian | 24 April, 2007 at 11:28 pm

Every one of us is different.

Some of us prefer protection and book a package holiday.

Some of us like taking risks, and organise our own holiday

Some of us like dealing with a travel company and book a dynamic holiday

The world would be a boring place if we all liked the same.

BUT, are programmes like this really highlighting the potential problems consumers could face abroad by booking the holiday themselves, or, is it the travel industry worried about the 11million DIY consumers increasing.

I’m going away in October for a week, and I’ll be booking a package holiday, any other time of the year, I usually book the holiday myself. Package holidays tend to be cheaper than DIY during some times of the year, so it’s working out which is best for you.

Darren Cronian | 24 April, 2007 at 11:33 pm

Thanks Lee.

I’ll contact them at some stage in the next week, as I would be interested to hear their opinions on accommodation only sites, and the lack of them signing up to associations like TTA.

Craig | 25 April, 2007 at 1:38 am

Like Lee Harrison I was shocked to hear that it was cheaper to book a holiday for 2 adults and 2 children as 4 adults. I’ll cetainly be trying this out the next time I book our family holiday.

Sorry Rohan, the programme was only 30 minutes long, they can only put on so much in that time. Of Course every body is going to be defensive over DIY packages, and it’s not until it goes wrong that people learn the hard way.
A £300.00 saving is considerable, but if it goes wrong that’s when the Costs can escalate.
Take some clients of ours who Booked a Package to Austria, the Tour Operator issued the Business class tickets incorrectly and had forgotten to include the E-ticket Numbers. Yes The Airline had the seats booked, they had them reserved for the Clients as per their passport details, but no ticket numbers meant no proof of payment, and the Airline refused them boarding. This was on a Sunday, and we got a call from the client, after a few Telephone calls from ourselves to Heatrhrow and Vienna, we were able to pay again for the clients tickets at a cost of £3000.
Had the Clients booked this as a DIY package they would have been on there own.
The Tour operator apologised and compensated both us and the client

Karen Bryan | 25 April, 2007 at 11:17 am

Interesting to read these comments by the MD of Teletext:
http://www.travelmole.com/stories/1117694.php
He seems to be agreeing with you, Darren, that the programme did not present a balanced, informed view.

Darren Cronian | 25 April, 2007 at 12:47 pm

Thanks for the link Karen.

I’ll check it out.

Darren Cronian | 25 April, 2007 at 4:06 pm

Lee, if that holiday had been DIY, wouldn’t the consumer have booked the flight with the airline direct, therefore, if the ticket numbers hadn’t been included on their ticket, the airline would be able to investigate the query in their own system, rather than the consumer, contacting the travel agent, and the travel agent, contacting the tour operator?

Or am I missing something [probably am!]

Sarah Bennett | 27 April, 2007 at 9:51 pm

I do DIY all the time, without fail.

I prefer to organise my own trips.

Please post a comment